Car 54, Where Are You? (1961)

S2E14 Stop Thief

When the boys accidentally catch the Captain practicing lines for a play in his office, they mistakenly believe he's a thief. In an attempt to protect his reputation, they take it upon themselves to "retrieve" his Christmas gifts. As Christmas Eve unfolds, they scramble to fix their misunderstanding and set things straight before the holiday arrives. Will they manage to resolve the situation in time?