Nightmare Next Door (2011)

S9E7 Into The Woods

When Jessi Evans and Jake Wheeler head out for a fishing trip and fail to return, the residents of Norris City, IL, begin to worry. Their fears deepen when Jake's truck is discovered at an old, deserted house, with a body in the back. As detectives delve into the case, they uncover a shocking revelation that shakes this deeply religious community to its foundation.