Law & Order: Criminal Intent (2001)

S2E26 Return Engagement (1)

When David Lewis, who has been living under the name Andrew Strauss, arrives in Colorado Springs, Mike finds herself torn between him and Sully, as she believed David had perished in the Civil War. Meanwhile, Horace and Myra face wedding-related stress as the townspeople begin to meddle in their wedding preparations, creating tension in their relationship. Andrew Strauss/David Lewis is portrayed by Maxwell Caulfield.